How to fix carriers

[Marcanbus_NA]

Just increase the amount of exp for shooting down planes! 

Is that too hard to do?

 

It would fix every problem with CVs.

 

IJN CVs could have the damage potential advantage

US CVs could have the Air superiority advantage

 

But both would do the same amount of exp

 

I can't think of any scenario where this would not work

 

 

 

 

[J30_Reinhardt]

...or...

do away with 'national flavor'. Just have the planes and squadron numbers be the difference.

[QuantumEntropy]

But if you have AS that means you can negate the damage advantage for the IJN

 

More planes > Damage

[MeKanism]

If it was that simple, it would have implemented already.

[Skeem689]

I feel like I've seen a carbon copy of this thread somewhere. 

[Wo_9]

i feel like my thread contributed to this. typical

[QuantumEntropy]

CVs are hard to fix .

[Marcanbus_NA]

But if you have AS that means you can negate the damage advantage for the IJN

 

More planes > Damage

 

even if you try you can't destroy every planes 

 

2 or 3 fighter squads can't stop 5 or 6 DBs/TBs

[Shadowrigger1]

Doesn't even come close to "Fixing" Carriers

[yUPPatriots]

proposed carrier solution

 

[Marcanbus_NA]

proposed carrier solution

 

 

I don't understand the video

 

Is that a potato?

[Marcanbus_NA]

Doesn't even come close to "Fixing" Carriers

 

do you mind explaining why?

[QuantumEntropy]

 

even if you try you can't destroy every planes 

 

2 or 3 fighter squads can't stop 5 or 6 DBs/TBs

 

The power of a strife

 

I saw 5 TB/DB gone in one strife by 1 fighter squad

 

Your ideea ok but not practical in an way or other

[bad_arcade_kitty]

make it so killing a cv give you silver and xp regardless what team they are in

 

...the problem is fixed

[Marcanbus_NA]

 

The power of a strife

 

I saw 5 TB/DB gone in one strife by 1 fighter squad

 

Your ideea ok but not practical in an way or other

 

Only an idiot would put all his planes in the same pack

 

it can easily be avoided if you spread your planes around

[LordBenjamin]

I agree that planes being shot down should reward more XP but I don't think it would "fix" CVs or anything.  It'd just encourage more teamwork cruiser skills instead of DE which is what cruisers typically take.

[Marcanbus_NA]

I agree that planes being shot down should reward more XP but I don't think it would "fix" CVs or anything.  It'd just encourage more teamwork cruiser skills instead of DE which is what cruisers typically take.

 

What will it not fix?

 

Everyone says it won't fix anything but they never say why

[IronWolfV]

How to fix carriers. Nuke it from orbit and start over.

[QuantumEntropy]

 

Only an idiot would put all his planes in the same pack

 

it can easily be avoided if you spread your planes around

 

From all my 3000 + games i can tell you that 90% of the CVs put their planes in one spot

[spartenkila]

I do agree that shooting down planes should get xp ... and if it is getting xp getting a lot more xp and credits.

 

But that doesn't fix CV and even if it did that totally puts people into a corner where if you want to do strike then you HAVE to pick IJN and if you want AS then you HAVE to pick US... that's just stupid.

 

we need a way for each nation to be able to do what ever the player wants to do and it feel fun and rewarding for all play styles with it still being fair to each nation.

 

I am not saying I know how to do it I am just stating my opinions. 

[BlazerSparta]

This just changes which strategy/ship happens to be OP in the current meta.

 

CVs will not be fixed without a complete rework of the class.

[Marcanbus_NA]

I do agree that shooting down planes should get xp ... and if it is getting xp getting a lot more xp and credits.

 

But that doesn't fix CV and even if it did that totally puts people into a corner where if you want to do strike then you HAVE to pick IJN and if you want AS then you HAVE to pick US... that's just stupid.

 

we need a way for each nation to be able to do what ever the player wants to do and it feel fun and rewarding for all play styles with it still being fair to each nation.

 

I am not saying I know how to do it I am just stating my opinions. 

 

I don't see the problem with national favor

 

You should choose a ship based on it's playstyle 

 

Take WoT as an exemple, almost every tier 10 is different. If you want a certain playstyle, you choose a certain line of tanks

 

what is the point in grinding different nations if they all play the same? That would be boring as hell

 

They managed to make all the tier 10 cruisers play differently, why not do the same for carriers?

[spartenkila]

 

I don't see the problem with national favor

 

You should choose a ship based on it's playstyle 

 

Take WoT as an exemple, almost every tier 10 is different. If you want a certain playstyle, you choose a certain line of tanks

 

what is the point in grinding different nations if they all play the same? That would be boring as hell

 

They managed to make all the tier 10 cruisers play differently, why not do the same for carriers?

 

Maybe your right and I see your point.

 

However, they do already play differently and I feel like if you make it too different than people are just going to say one nation is OP and the other is terrible and all players will only play 1 nation.

 

Prime example is the US BB vs the IJN BB... I am generalizing here but it seems that the consensus is that the US BB is sub-par while the Yamato is much more powerful approaching OP when you talk about BB 1v1 combat.

 

I don't know the solution but I can apparently point out all the problems  

[Marcanbus_NA]

 

Maybe your right and I see your point.

 

However, they do already play differently and I feel like if you make it too different than people are just going to say one nation is OP and the other is terrible and all players will only play 1 nation.

 

Prime example is the US BB vs the IJN BB... I am generalizing here but it seems that the consensus is that the US BB is sub-par while the Yamato is much more powerful approaching OP when you talk about BB 1v1 combat.

 

I don't know the solution but I can apparently point out all the problems  

 

The Yamato vs Montana thing is an issue that needs to be fixed too. They could easily fix it but they don't even try

If you look at the other classes at tier 10 they are pretty much balanced (Des Moines could use a buff but other than that it is fine)

[Gaishu_Isshoku]

You can make shooting down planes more rewarding, but that won't change the fact that AS loadouts are simply less impactful on the game and much much harder to carry with.