Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
You need to play a total of 20 battles to post in this section.
Shrayes_Bhagavatula

World of Warships Comparison Test 2: Tier 7 DD Duel

13 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles

World of Warships Ship Comparison Test Number 2: Tier 7 Gunship Destroyer Brawl: Maass, Mahan, Minsk, and Jervis versus Vauquelin

 

JOJO INTENSIFIES

 

Destroyer brawls are intense, and not just for the people who get involved in them, but also those people who are spectating it, wondering who will come out on top, and who will get sunk, or who will get smashed by the Venezia that popped out from nowhere. Still, there’s no Venezia at Tier 7, so it’s easier to evaluate these five gunship destroyers. The oldest of the quintet, Mahan is easily one of the most maligned ships at her tier, as she begins to promote the torpedo-centric playstyle of Japanese torpedo boats with her upgraded fish, rather than the gunboat tactics of the Nicholas and Farragut. Regardless, with 5 American 127mm/38 guns, she boasts a hybridization that few can match effectively. The Leberecht Maass, otherwise known as KMS Z1, is the German answer to the Mahan. While she cannot boast the torpedo armament of the Mahan, she makes up for it with a powerful AP punch from her 128mm guns, while also having better stealth and durability than Mahan and faster moving, more effective and more dangerous waterborne warheads. The Minsk is the embodiment of the true gunship style of destroyers. Her stealth is quite poor, but she boasts 5 Russian 130mm guns that make hiding largely a nonissue, thanks to their flat ballistics and massive damage, as well as her incredible speed of 43 knots, the fastest for her tier, as well as a good chunk of HP. The Jervis, the only Brit in the test, has the best stealth in this test, as well as a powerful broadside of 6 120mm guns, as well as fairly good torpedo armament. The Vauquelin, the Frenchman, is the newest of these ships. She’s largely gimmick-laden, like most French ships, but she boasts several unique quirks, such as unusual HP distribution that allows her to last longer, 5 French 139mm guns, the largest in the test, a reload booster, and an enhanced speed boost with greater boost power and longer duration over all other ships in this test. So then, I know what you’re thinking: Where are the Japanese, the Gadjah Mada, and the Z-39, Leningrad, Haida, Błyskawica, and the Sims?  The Japanese are still largely torpedo focused with the Akatsuki and the Shiratsuyu at this tier, the Gadjah Mada’s Deepwater torpedo armament means it cannot one-shot destroyers with a surprise torpedo strike at all, and the last five are all premiums ( you know the drill with Premiums ). Well, what are you standing around for? Let’s go!


 

5th place: The Minsk ( 17 / 25 )

Pros: Actually fast, pretty decent stealth for a Russian DD, god-tier shell arcs

Cons: Huge, sluggish, sluggish turrets, pathetic torpedoes

 

When we think about Russian DDs, we generally think flat ballistics, high speed, and huge ships. Case in point, the last place finisher in this test, the Minsk. The big reason here, as I stated, is her huge size. She’s almost comparable to the Vauquelin in this comparison, but the Frenchman has an unusual HP pool distribution that allows it to take more damage than usual. The Minsk also has another issue in it’s handling. Now, the Minsk is by no means slow, at 43 knots, but has extremely sluggish handling thanks to a large turning radius. It has one of the fastest rudders at her tier, beaten only by the Leningrad, but a 690 meter turning circle, which is only 20 meters shorter than the Akizuki, makes her vulnerable when trying to turn full circle. Another issue is her turrets. Now, she has some pretty excellent guns. The 5 130mm B-13 guns boast excellent range, excellent arcs, and fast reload. However, her turret traverse of 9.7 degrees per second is far behind all of the other DDs in this test, with the only one similar being the Vauquelin, and the only one worse being the Maass. This would put her on the good side of things, but there’s another issue in terms of dueling other DDs: her torpedoes. This is not an uncommon issue among Soviet DDs, but with just 4 kilometers of range and pretty low damage, she has the worst torpedoes in the test. Remember, a gunship like the Minsk must also have good back-up torpedoes to complement her guns, and unfortunately, it doesn’t have those back-ups, like the next four finishers in this test.

 

Fourth Place: The Jervis ( 18/25 )

Pros: Defensive Hydro, best stealth in test, powerful broadside, great torpedoes, very smol bote, lots of smokes.

Cons: Radar cruisers, British 120mm guns, second worst torpedo range in test, no access to engine boost, lots of smokes means that the smokes are terrible, second worst HP pool in test

 

I thought Jervis was good, wasn’t it? So did I, until I actually tested this thing. She has her merits, such as her 3km ranged defensive Hydro and best-in-test stealth, but she does have downsides. Let’s start with that Hydro. While it lasts an absurd 3 minutes long, it lacks the power of the Leberecht Maass’ German Hydro, which has a 4 kilometer ship spotting range and a torpedo spotting range of over 3 kilometers, which gives the Maass ample warning time to react properly, compared to the Jervis’ 3 kilometer range on both torpedoes and ships. There are no issues about stealth, however. With CE, she can reach a minimum detection range of just 6.3 kilometers, which works both in theory and in practice. The only issue here is either when she gets radared when she gets spotted and ends up fighting her counterparts. She has 6 120mm guns in 3 twin turrets, which gives her the most convenient layout of all the DDs in the test, but these guns have a rather long reload of 5 seconds, lower damage, and poorer ballistics than the American in this test, the Mahan. Also, she has the most middle of the pack torpedo armament of all the destroyers in this test. She might have 10 of them, which can be single launched, and do massive damage, but they are let down by a  rather slow speed of 59 knots, and, despite having a longer range than those of the Minsk, it’s still just 7 kilometers, compared to the Vauquelin’s 8 kilometer, 68 knot fish, Maass’ 8.5km, 65 knot fish, and Mahan’s 9.2km, 55 knot speed torps. Yes, the Mahan might have just 55 knot speed torps that do just 12k a pop, but they have 2 kilometers greater range and better detectability, so there’s that. Lastly, it’s her durability under fire that put her here. At just 14,300 HP, she’s only 200 HP better than the Mahan, and she also lacks Engine Boost to get herself out of a tricky situation, with the only save being the improved British DD acceleration boost. The one ace up here sleeve her is the fast cooldown smoke generator, of which she has 5 charges base, but they only have a 10 second deploy time and a 40 second duration, and when an Atlanta pokes with radar around the corner, you're toast. Not so much with the next three, however.


 

Third Place: The Mahan ( 19 / 25 ) ( TIE )

Pros: American 127mm guns, 12 torpedoes with a 9.2km range, turns tight, American smoke, excellent stealth, DFAA, god-tier rudder shift.

 

Cons: Pathetic torpedo damage, American 127mm guns, tight turning only helps around islands, lacks utility thanks to the fact that DFAA is useless these days, Radar cruisers

 

As the oldest ship in this test ( literally was out during Closed Beta ), the Mahan has grown quite long in the tooth. The fact that she pulled a third place victory is something I hadn’t really expected out of the old girl. Let’s start with her good points. For starters, she boasts 5 American 127mm/38 guns, with the best in test 3.3 second reload and fairly decent range and quickest in test turret traverse of 15 degrees per second. Unfortunately, these guns are also a bit of a double edged sword, as the third turret has somewhat poor firing angles, and the ballistics of the guns is poor beyond 6 kilometers, something that the last place Minsk wouldn’t mind boasting about. The Mahan also has torpedoes, mind you. The torpedoes have a range of 9.2 kilometers when fully upgraded, and she has 12 of them in 4 Triple launchers, one on each side and one down the center. However, these torpedoes are slow and deal pathetic damage to targets, using the same warheads from the Tier 6 Farragut. She also boasts the best AA in the test, but that’s something I also didn’t mention with the other DDs, for one reason. She’s the only one with access to DFAA , boosting her AA on her top hull, but she has to sacrifice one main battery turret to make the most out of it. This isn’t worthwhile, as DFAA is useless these days, and all other ships will out DPM you this way. She does boast the second best stealth and best smoke generator and maneuverability in this test, but there’s no point in using it when every American Cruiser, Russian Cruiser, and British Light Cruiser and their mother’s got Radar. Not to mention, she has the smallest HP pool in the whole test, at just 14,100 HP. She does have the best agility in the test however, with a 560 meter turning circle and 2.7 second rudder shift only let down by 35 knots of speed. However, she’s still in the middle of the pack, and the reason why she was able to eke out a third place finish was because she boasts better capacity than the Minsk and Jervis, but not so much as to win, not as much as the next two on this list.


 

Second Place: The Vauquelin ( 19 / 25 ) ( TIE )

Pros: Reload Booster, French Engine Boost, Titanic HP pool, brutal torpedo armament, unusual HP Distribution, guns are no joke, reload booster gives massive burst damage potential

Cons: NO Smoke, jokingly slow without engine boost active, huge detection range, torpedoes are only 8 kilometer range, sluggish turrets

 

The Vauquelin could have made first place, but there are several things that are holding her back, including that over-reliance on gimmicks, such as that boosted Engine Boost and Main Battery Reload Booster. She does have lots of good points, though, so we’ll start with that. She boasts the largest HP pool in the test, at 18,100 HP fully upgraded. She also has the French DD gimmick in that she has an unusual HP pool distribution, which means that some areas can be saturated with damage and she will take less damage in return. She also has powerful guns that make whittling down that HP pool a bit of a chore for other DDs. She packs 5 139mm guns in single gun mounts, with a 5 second base reload, 13km range, and Main Battery Reload booster, which compensates for the longer than average reload and middle of the pack shell arcs by cutting her reload time in half for 15 seconds or so. However, she also has a pretty slow turret traverse that makes turning duels a hassle, making run-and-gun attacks much better than wagon-wheel fights. Her torpedo armament is also similarly interesting in this regard. She has 9 torpedo tubes on her top hull in three triple tubes, with a layout similar to Mahan’s. The torpedoes have an 8km range, 68 knots of speed, and rather powerful warheads, though they are towards the middle of the pack on damage. To get into effective range to use this, she boasts a French engine boost that increases her speed by 20% for up to 3 minutes, which gives her a top speed of over 43 knots. However, without the boost active, the speed is a fairly pedestrian 35 knots, which is among the slowest of all the DDs in the test, with only Jervis being worse. Her worst problem of all, however, is her concealment. Her massive surface detection of 7.7 kilometers is the worst in the test, and while she can stealth torpedo like all the other DDs in this test (save the Minsk), the buffer isn’t that great without CE, and while Jervis can’t even stealth torpedo without CE, she can at least hide and do it thanks to the fact that she actually has a smoke screen, as opposed to Vauquelin, who doesn’t even have smoke to work with, let alone even the terrible smoke of the first place finisher in this test.


 

First Place: The Leberecht Maass ( 20 / 25 )

Pros: German Hydro, best torpedoes in this test, excellent ballistics on a fast reload for her guns, brutal in close quarters engagements with AP, huge HP pool

Cons: Guns don’t reload as fast as Mahan’s, Middle of the pack concealment, forgettable HE performance, AP only works against broadsides, horridly slow turret traverse, meh smoke

 

How the heck did a German DD make first place against a Russian and American DD? Sit back and read, this is a LOT simpler than it looks. For starters, Maass also boasts a huge HP pool, though she lacks that unique HP distribution that makes the Frenchman so durable under fire. However, she also has some serious capacity to make that French HP pool look silly as anything. Her 128mm guns reload a whole second faster than all the others in this test, save the Mahan. She also has much better ballistics than the Mahan, to say nothing of the ammunition she uses to complement that, with the best AP ammunition in the test, as per standard for German DDs, though the HE performance is uninspiring, as per usual with German DDs, as is the horribly long turret traverse of 22.5 seconds for a full 180 (!). When it comes to torpedoes,I initially considered her fish to be utter turds compared to the others ( except Minsk), lacking the range and stealth of the American or the raw alpha of the Brit. However, they have the fastest reload in the test, at 90 seconds, and with 8.5km of range 65 knots of speed, and 14,400 damage a pop, they are also some of the best torpedoes in her matchmaking for gunship DDs in general, so ignore the fact that I even considered them to be turds. I mean, Mahan does reload 3 seconds faster, but with TAE the reload speed is pretty much the same, so it hardly matters. The Maass is also pretty agile, with 37 knots of speed and a 640 meter turning circle only hampered by a 4.2 second rudder shift, which is the worst in this test by a long shot. However, it’s her two other things that make her stand out, her concealment and her hydro. She can get down to a detection range of just 6.7 kilometers, which is tied for dead last of the pack for detection, with only the Minsk being as bad. That being said, she’s nipping hard on the heels of the Mahan and Vauquelin, being just 100 meters worse, and that 100 meters means that you already know that they’re there and ready to pounce, even when the three with a smokescreen try and hide. The reason for that statement, and what gave her the 1st place medal, is her Hydroacoustic search. This is all down to judicious usage of smoke cover and smoke firing penalties. With Jervis’ hydro, you can only see them at three kilometers, by which time you're already within smoke firing detection range. The Maass, on the other hand, can spot targets at 4 kilometers, which gives her ample time to react and mow them down before they can react and strike back. The only thing that really lets her down here is her worse than average smokescreen, with a 20 second deploy time and 77 second uptime. Overall, she’s the best of these 5 ships. A true German Jaeger who fights to the last drop of blood and shred of steel. If you thought German DDs were mediocre, middle of the pack, or any worse, think again. The Leberecht Maass just won a Comparo Test, and it doesn’t look as if it will lose one for a while to come ( of course, we’ll have to see about that new-fangled Pan-Euro DD, the Skane, looks quite good to fight against it)



 

Final Tally

5th Place: Minsk

Armor: 3 / 5

Armaments: 4 / 5

AA: 2 / 5

Maneuverability: 5 / 5

Stealth: 3 / 5

Total: 17 / 25

Verdict: Russia builds a Russian DD, again

 

4th Place: Jervis

Armor: 3 / 5

Armaments: 4 / 5

AA: 2 / 5

Maneuverability: 4 / 5

Stealth: 5 / 5

Total: 18 / 25

Verdict: Meh party with a slight taste of goodness

 

3rd Place: Mahan

Armor: 3 / 5

Armaments: 4 / 5

AA: 4 / 5

Maneuverability: 4 / 5

Stealth: 4 /5

Total: 19 / 25

Verdict: America doesn’t always come first

 

2nd Place: Vauquelin

Armor: 5 / 5

Armaments: 5 / 5

AA: 2 / 5

Maneuverability: 4 / 5

Stealth: 3 / 5

Total: 19 / 25

Verdict: Slightly undercooked Turbo Escargot

 

1st Place: Leberecht Maass

Armor: 4 / 5

Armaments: 5 / 5

AA: 3 / 5

Maneuverability: 3 / 5

Stealth: 5 / 5

Total: 20 / 25 (Hydro gives a 1 point bonus thanks to it’s utility )

Verdict: Who says Germany is underpowered in this game?


 

As one final note, I would like to thank my younger brother for suggesting this comparison test for you guys. I received some pretty good feedback on the last comparo test, so I used that for this one. Thank you all so much.

 

Like I said in the Richelieu Review, the Roma will be coming up as the next reviewed ship, courtesy of Clammboy’s suggestion ( do give him a +1 if you get the chance )

 

And the next comparo test?

 

                                         DOUBLE BRAWLER BATTLESHIP HIGH SEA SMACKDOWN

                                             TIER 10 GRO𝜷ER KURFÜRST VERSUS TIER 10 OHIO

                                 Which one of these brawling BBs comes out alive in a death battle?                                               

                                    Find out on March 7, 2020, Right here, on SUPER SMACKDOWN

 

Also, the next ship review will be announced on February 25, 2020, once polling closes. I can’t say what it will be, but all i’ll say is that it will be a Russian Battleship, either a tech line ship, or a premium. You can vote on the poll found in general game discussion

 

Peace!

Edited by Shrayes_Bhagavatula
Reverted to standard format, due to complaints of being unable to view topic
  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles

*Oh, but Shrayes, the Gadjah Mada is also a Tier 7 Non Premium DD with excellent capacity, it's the best DD in the world!*

Yeah, well DWT's dont' do crap against DDs now do they

I was also going to make a joke about Italian SAP here, but I thought it would hit too hard for this test....

I'll see myself out now.....

Edit: I dropped this early because my schedule is packed tomorrow. Also, the Roma Review isn't done yet, so I had to put that there as well...

 

Edited by Shrayes_Bhagavatula

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
927 posts
10,245 battles

Actually only adds to 15...

 

5th Place: Minsk

Armor: 3 / 5

Armaments: 3 / 5

AA: 2 / 5

Maneuverability: 4 / 5

Stealth: 3 / 5

Total: 17 / 25

Verdict: Russia builds a Russian DD, again

 

 

And the Vaquelin description has a line which does not reflect Minsk issue:

while she can stealth torpedo like all the other DDs in this test

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles

oh dear me, seems I dropped some points off of Minsk by accident....

and that "Save Minsk" Line

Gimme a sec, I'll fix that

Thank you for pointing out that issue!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
237
[CHASE]
[CHASE]
Beta Testers
391 posts
11,775 battles

how is Maass 5/5 on stealth? it has the worst stealth for its tier other than the open water gunboats. And I'm pretty sure Mahan has better concealment than Maas (6.7km vs. 6.8km). So while I agreed that Maas is a good ship, your scoring system doesn't seem to reflect the ships' true stats.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,084
[TSG4B]
Volunteer Moderator
2,923 posts
15,391 battles

it nice to do such thing, however, it kinda bored with wall of large font bold black text ......

suggestion: have some short replay clips as pic worth 1000000 words.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
569
[LEGIT]
Members
2,334 posts
31,797 battles

What about Sims B?  It seems to be one of the few DD's I can play OK in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles

The first question is answered because the Maass has Hydroacoustic Search with a 4km Ship spotting range, meaning it can shoot DDs from inside smoke, or from outside smoke without exposing itself to return fire

As for the second one, the Sims B is a Black version of Sims, which, as I stated, is a premium ship, and as such, will not be featured in this test

Thank you all for your questions!

Edit: I never really played the Sims. I played the Benson with C hull, which was about as close to the Sims as I could get, but I have nothing there other than that, unfortunately

Edited by Shrayes_Bhagavatula

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
605
[TOAST]
[TOAST]
Members
1,444 posts
10,195 battles

I donno... I don't think I'd put Vauquelin so high and I really like that ship. The best quality it has is firepower that only comes in bursts.  The other things, like you said are gimmicky. Good DD with decent detection for what it is though. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles
4 minutes ago, Vekta408 said:

I donno... I don't think I'd put Vauquelin so high and I really like that ship. The best quality it has is firepower that only comes in bursts.  The other things, like you said are gimmicky. Good DD with decent detection for what it is though. 

Kinda makes you wonder why the Martel placed Last in the previous test huh?

In terms of Gimmicks, the Vauquelin and Martel are no different, with both Engine Boost and Reload Booster. The reason why the Vauquelin placed second instead of dead last is because it can use those gimmicks better. Also, that hull gimmick literally gives it the best survivability of all the Tier 7 DDs, never mind this test.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,058 posts
4,376 battles
3 hours ago, ObiphanKenobi said:

it nice to do such thing, however, it kinda bored with wall of large font bold black text ......

suggestion: have some short replay clips as pic worth 1000000 words.

I'll try that. However, I lack that capacity at this point, as I do lack for the tools or the time

I'm just a high schooler, after all...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×