Jump to content
You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section.
penguinsstar

Two people with same exp earned on a losing team in ranked battles; Losing a star; Bug

5 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

7
[DAKI]
[DAKI]
Members
50 posts
6,597 battles

Issue: Two players on the top of a losing team with same exp earned in ranked battles, one player loses a star and the other doesn't.

Expected Result: Both players should not lose a star since they have an equal amount of exp.

How to replicate: Two players on a losing team in ranked battles with the same amount of exp earned.

So in the post screen scoreboard, it is clearly indicated that I have the equal amount of the exp and that I have also not lost a star. The only problem is that when the battle ended, it showed the animation of losing a star (unfortunately I don't have screen shot of that) and up until now (five days later) there still has been no indication of where that star went. 

I know there are issues with the interface and that there is a visual bug going around where it doesn't show the amount of stars accurately, but I believe this may be a separate issue as it has persisted over several client restarts and (probably some server restarts too) and the fact that it is from a fringe case of equal top exps. 

I don't run modifications and run a vanilla client. I have already submitted a bug report. I am just making a forum post to inform others in case some other people may also have experienced this bug.

So far, I've found one other person who also experienced this alleged issue. @alphadog007

20180510_233226_PASC020-Des-Moines-1948_44_Path_warrior.wowsreplay

shot-18_05.10_23_47.01-0587.thumb.jpg.2497f6ef27673111f8e6fd5f8c2834c2.jpg

Spoiler

shot-18_05.10_23_58.02-0837.thumb.jpg.c0aef895b196c5c63f0f52854cd10d9c.jpg

 

Spoiler

Screenshot_36.thumb.png.88a1d4c3ebeb1b180bb1cfaeb2834872.png

 

Edited by penguinsstar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7
[DAKI]
[DAKI]
Members
50 posts
6,597 battles

Update: So apparently players with the same amount of exp don't always save a star?...

1.thumb.PNG.2a09dc45b138bb8fc7454a5a24878c21.PNG

2.thumb.PNG.cf595466761473c93e8946e3ee561eb0.PNG

shot-18_05.10_23_47.01-0587.thumb.jpg.2497f6ef27673111f8e6fd5f8c2834c2.jpg

Edit: Ticket ID 2566510: Progression and Rewards

Edited by penguinsstar

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
72
[PLPTS]
Members
757 posts
13,295 battles

Just so no one is shocked if it ever occurs, but you have to WIN to gain stars. If its a tie, (almost) everyone loses stars. I have no idea what happens to the top player on each team, eg. who gets to keep their star, since that is code dependent, but the loss is based on the rules.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
55
[GRRR]
Members
63 posts
13,914 battles

This just happened to me. WG will probably see it as a problem with the team score report rather than an issue where the star should be preserved for all players tied for first place on the losing team. There's no reason to be stingy here; if multiple players tie for first place in points on the losing team then just let them keep their star.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×