Jump to content
You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section.
Stauffenberg44

Admiral Scheer--Graf Spee's Successful Sister Ship

27 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles

5af8cd505d71a_AdmiralSheer2.jpg.efc19048b95044219aed689cee7a1970.jpg

Admiral Scheer at Narvik in the summer of 1942

 

The Graf Spee and her fate is well-known; far less appreciated are the exploits of her sister ship Admiral Scheer.

From active participation in the Spanish Civil War, to Atlantic convoy raiding, Arctic convoy interdiction off Murmansk, and an extended foray in the Indian Ocean in which Admiral Scheer had steamed more than 53,000 miles (85,300 km) and sunk or captured 16 merchant ships totaling 99,059 tons, Admiral Scheer far exceeded the accomplishments of her sister. In all of World War 2, the Admiral Scheer under Captain Theodor Krancke was by far the most successful capital ship commerce raider of the conflict. It's a pity she may not appear in WoWs.

Historical notes:

Spoiler

Admiral Scheer was the second of the three Deutschland class heavy cruisers ordered and funded by the Reichsmarine of the Weimar Republic in 1926. This class of ships were often referred to as "pocket battleship" - vessels smaller than a conventional battleship though bigger than any ocean-going cruiser at the time. Serving with the Kriegsmarine (German Navy) during World War 2, the Admiral Scheer was aptly named after German Admiral Reinhard Scheer who commanded the Kaiserliche Marine High Seas Fleet at the Battle of Jutland, the largest naval battle of World War 1. Scheer survived the war and died in 1928. Five years later, his namesake was launched and christened by Scheer's daughter, Marianne.

During the inter-war years (the period between World War 1 and World War 2) Germany made a habit of side-stepping international treaty rules limiting the number and tonnage of warships allowed to the Kriegsmarine (based on the post-World War I Treaty of Versailles. As such, the Reichsmarine classified the Scheer as a smaller armored ship, or "Panzerschiff". This subterfuge of the class placed him in the eyes of the world as complying with the treaty rules for, at least on paper, he was a small warship. The heavy cruiser was one of the few ships in naval history that has often been referred to as male by its crew and referred to as "he"instead of the usual feminine gender use of "her" utilized in most navies of the world, even today.

The Scheer's first mission began in July 1936 when he was sent to Spain to evacuate German civilians caught up in the Spanish Civil War. The vessel was also called on to spy on Soviet ships carrying supplies to the Communist Republicans while protecting ships delivering German weapons to Franco's Nationalist Fascist Army. On May 31st,1937 he and several German planes bombarded the Republican town of Almeria, Spain, in response to a previous air attack on the sister ship KMS Deutschland. The British papers condemned it as a criminal act and, upon further review, only a few deaths were attributed to the limited shelling. By the end of June 1938 the Scheer had completed a total of eight deployments to Spain in support of the Fascist Spanish government. He returned to Germany for a refit, having his superstructure lowered for a reduced profile and radar image. After the refit, the Kriegsmarine reclassified him as a heavy cruiser for shore bombardment and supply delivery to Spain was not what Hitler had intended for his pocket battleships - commerce raiding of convoys was more the forte of this class
.
A convoy was a group of ships traveling together for mutual support and protection - this tactic was utilized before and during the Second World War. The British adopted a convoy system, initially voluntary and later compulsory for all merchant ships, when World War 2 was declared. The first convoys emerged from Canadian ports and then soon after from American ports. A Commodore with naval experience was assigned to oversee the assignment of these ships and their cargos. He would develop a master plan for each ship and they would be assigned to a particular spot in the convoy "box". The box required each ship to maintain a certain speed and keep an assigned distance from the ship along her bow and stern and to her on port and star board sides. No doubt this required a lot of discipline for each ship and crew, especially when considering operations at night, often running in complete darkness so as not to provide easy prey to enemy submarines.

Convoy HX-84 was assigned 38 merchant ships with cargos to be shipped from Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada sailing to Liverpool, England under the command of Commodore H.B. Maltby. The vital cargos being carried by the ships in the convoy ranged from general merchandise, steel, military trucks and maize. The convoy sailed out on October 28th, 1940 taking a secret route only known to the captains at the time of sailing. Due to the lack of warships early in the war, the convoy's security was handled in three legs; first the local leg escort from Halifax was composed of the Canadian destroyers Columbia and St. Francis. The most dangerous center ocean leg was handled by the HMS Jervis Bay and the local escort close to English shores from Liverpool were the destroyers HMS Hesperus and three accompanying Corvettes. The ocean leg was assigned to a converted armed merchant ship, formally the Aberdeen & Commonwealth liner, Jervis Bay. The Jervis Bay, built originally as a passenger ship, was taken over by the Admiralty in August of 1939. She was fitted out with 7 x 6-inch guns of World War 1 vintage with each gun attaining a maximum range of 15,000 yards (or 8.5 miles) at 28-degree maximum elevation. Painted grey for camouflage and manned by 255 crew men, she proudly hoisted the White Ensign of an ocean escort for Atlantic convoys.

The Admiral Scheer slipped quietly into the Atlantic on October 14th, 1940, searching for a convoy target. Its two Arado seaplanes were launched daily looking over the horizon for targets or enemy warships to contend with. On November 5th, 1940 one of the pilots spotted a convoy and, not seeing any warships, felt it was an unescorted target and promptly radioed the Scheer with the ship's location.

The Scheer proceeded towards the position as radioed by the seaplane. Sure enough, as the Scheer approached the target location, only a single ship was seen. Captain Kranckes problem was that if he steamed around or attacked the small freighter she could radio the speed and heading of the Scheer and convoy HX.84 could scatter. Krancke decided to approach the vessel at flank speed and ordered the target vessel to stop and not use her radio. The vessel turned out to be the banana boat SS Mopan of 7,909 tons. The Mopan's skipper decided to obey the German order primarily since they themselves had no life boats to use and it was November in the chilly Atlantic. Scheer stopped and took on the 76 crew members as prisoners before destroying the Mopan, this becoming the Scheer's first kill. The decision on the part of the Mopan took an approximately an hour, giving the rest of the convoy more time to react and less daylight for the Scheer to operate in. With daylight running out, Captain Kranckes ordered full speed ahead.

Scheer's problem now was that it was late afternoon and it would be ever more difficult to find additional targets after dark. Captain Fegen of the Jervis Bay also knew the convoy needed time to escape and made the decision to attack the Scheer directly. Jervis Bay dropped smoke floats as she closed the range between her and the pocket battleship. Jervis fired but all her initial volley shots fell short and soon the 11 inch shells from Scheer started to find the Jarvis Bay. Without deck armor, casualties proved heavy. Captain Fegen was on the bridge when it was hit and lost an arm in the ensuing actions. He continued to give orders, trying to close the range, but was subsequently killed when another shell hit the bridge. The destruction of the bridge and its crew included the lost of gunnery control. In this 24 minute battle at sea, most of the Jarvis Bay officers were killed and, with the ship ablaze stem to stern, the order was given to abandon. 198 men were lost in this one-sided battle. The Swedish freighter Stureholm found and saved the remaining 65 crewmen. Captain Fegen was posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross for Valor.

Scheer steamed past the Jervis Bay, still looking for the convoy. SS Kenbane Head of 5,225 tons was sunk with 24 hands being lost. SS Beaverford of 10,042 tons attempted to defend the convoy with minimal armament on board. The battle lasted for some time with Scheer firing on multiple targets. However, Beaverford went down with all 77 hands aboard. Scheer started using star shells to locate other ships in the dark and found the SS Maiden of 7,908 tons. She was sunk with all 91 hands aboard. Soon after, the SS Trewellard of 5,201 tons came into range and was sunk with one 11-inch shell, taking 16 merchant seamen with her to the bottom. In the distance Scheer spotted the SS Fresno City of 6,500 tons with a cargo of maise. Though this vessel almost slipped away, she was downed by the Scheer with all hands. Captain Kranckes was becoming concerned that the British screen from England could appear at any moment in the darkness. The Royal Navy had sent out several ships to trap the Admiral Scheer, but before they arrived, the Scheer slipped away to rendezvous with his oiler Nordmark. During the next two months, he found and sunk four more ships, capturing supplies, three ships and transferring the prisoners to the oiler Nordmark . Making a foray into the Indian Ocean in February of 1941, he sunk two more ships. Before they were sunk, however, a distress signal was sent out and picked up by British cruisers. The next day, Scheer sank a coal ship and followed up with an escaped back into the Atlantic. Captain Krancke sailed northwards and reached Kiel on April 1, 1941 - sailing over 46,000 nautical miles (85,000 km) at voyage's end.

Admiral Scheer stayed in the port of Kiel until early July 1942, trying to find and sink Arctic Convoy PQ-17. Thirty-six merchant ships left Reykjavik, Iceland and two made it thru with 34 ships sunk by German U-boats and aircraft. None were sunk by the Scheer, however, so in August 1942 he sailed into the Arctic Ocean to hunt convoys and establish a German presence in the USSR's Arctic region. This operation in the arctic was known as "Unternehmen Wunderland" in German and proved to be a large sortie.

In the ensuing action, Scheer damaged two Soviet patrol boats, bombarded and destroyed an Soviet meteorological station and sank an armed ice breaker Aleksandr Sibiryakov. Before the icebreaker sank, the crew sent a signal to the next station that the Scheer was heading to destroy - the Novy Dikson. Arriving at the harbor, he moved in to shell the ships and shore installations. The garrison there used a field howitzer against him, causing minor damage. He, in turn, badly damaged the two ships in the harbor and shelled the troops at the garrison, then returning to Narvik without finding any allied convoys in the Kara Sea.

Hitler's anger at the failings of the Kriegsmarine and his pocket battle ships to do any reasonable damage against the Allied convoys supplying the Soviet Union culminated. Its commander-in-chief, Admiral Raeder, was replaced by Admiral Donitz and the German surface fleet stayed in port from then on.

In 1944, Admiral Scheer provided artillery support for retreating German army units on the Sorve Peninsula. In January and February of 1945, he was again engaged in coastal bombardment operations, but with constant firing his gun barrels were worn out by March and he returned to Kiel. On the night of April 9th, 1945, a 300-strong RAF bombing raid on the dockyard critically struck the Scheer and he capsized while still tied up at the dock. Only 32 sailors were killed with most of the crew on shore leave.

In all of World War 2, the Admiral Scheer under Captain Theodor Krancke was by far the most successful capital ship commerce raider of the conflict, particularly in his foray into the Indian Ocean. After the war, his hull was scrapped and the dock was filled in to make a parking lot.

Ships sunk and captured by the KMS Scheer.

5 November 1940 - SS Mopan, British, 5,389tons - SUNK
5 November 1940 - HMS Jervis Bay, British, 14,164tons - SUNK IN COMBAT
5 November 1940 - SS Maidan, British, 7,908tons - SUNK
5 November 1940 - SS Trewellard, British, 5,201tons - SUNK
5 November 1940 - SS Kenbane Head, British, 5,225tons - SUNK
5 November 1940 - SS Beaverford, British, 10,142tons - SUNK
5 November 1940 - SS Fresno City, British, 4,995tons - SUNK
24 November 1940 - SS Port Hobart, British, 7,448tons - SUNK
1 December 1940 - SS Tribesman, British, 6,242tons - SUNK
17 December 1940 - SS Duquesa, British, 8,652tons - CAPTURED
17 January 1941 - SS Sandefjord, Norwegian, 8,083tons - CAPTURED
20 January 1941 - SS Barneveld, Dutch, 5,597tons - SUNK
20 January 1941 - SS Stanpark, British, 5,103tons - SUNK
20 February 1941 - SS British Advocate, British, 6,994tons - CAPTURED
20 February 1941 - SS Grigorios C., Greek, 2,546tons - SUNK
21 February 1941 - SS Canadian Cruiser, British, 6,992tons - SUNK
22 February 1941 - SS Rantau Pandjang, Dutch, 2,542tons - SUNK
25 August 1942 - SS Aleksandr Sibiryakov, Soviet, 1,384tons - SUNK IN COMBAT

from https://www.militaryfactory.com/ships/detail.asp?ship_id=KMS-Admiral-Scheer

 

 

 

5af8d073c9eaf_AdmiralSheer1.jpg.9da409fe88e4f164da1005eaf74e9e5a.jpg

 

 

Edited by Stauffenberg44
  • Cool 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
734
[HYDRO]
Members
1,585 posts
3,753 battles

Nice writeup +1! Though I think it's Scheer instead of Sheer. Btw, did the ship have any differences from the rest of the class, or were all identical ?

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
6 minutes ago, warheart1992 said:

Nice writeup +1! Though I think it's Scheer instead of Sheer. Btw, did the ship have any differences from the rest of the class, or were all identical ?

Ganz genau richtig! Corrected and thanks.

The three Deutschland-class "Panzerschiffe" seem to be identical but will look more closely when I have more time. Or if anyone else wants to, pls do.

Edited by Stauffenberg44

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
977
Members
4,566 posts
6,505 battles

Nice.  Super duper informative. Of course the Graf Spee is the one most remember and have heard of because of her big fight with the Brits and her rather dramatic demise and her Captain's suicide...etc. blah blah. Spee did sink a lotta stuff however.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
517
[POP]
Members
1,166 posts
15,101 battles
21 minutes ago, Stauffenberg44 said:

Ganz genau richtig! Corrected and thanks.

The three Deutschland-class "Panzerschiffe" seem to be identical but will look more closely when I have more time. Or if anyone else wants to, pls do.

HI Stauff

There were some difference's to all 3 ships as I recall but I to would have go digging through boxes to find my books  so I will get back to you on that one when I can.

Another thing positive thoughts :Smile_Default:  we want all 3 Deutschland class ships in game as premiums specially Admiral Scheer  in her 1945 AA configuration she still wont bring the sky down with her guns but she will give it a dam good try.

By 1945 she was bristling with flak, just thinking about it now off the top of my head I'm pretty certain he bridge was a different design in fact I think all 3 ships had different bridges.

You have got me interested now will have go find that book.

cheers :Smile_honoring:  

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
1 minute ago, tm63au said:

HI Stauff

There were some difference's to all 3 ships as I recall but I to would have go digging through boxes to find my books  so I will get back to you on that one when I can.

Another thing positive thoughts :Smile_Default:  we want all 3 Deutschland class ships in game as premiums specially Admiral Scheer  in her 1945 AA configuration she still wont bring the sky down with her guns but she will give it a dam good try.

By 1945 she was bristling with flak, just thinking about it now off the top of my head I'm pretty certain he bridge was a different design in fact I think all 3 ships had different bridges.

You have got me interested now will have go find that book.

cheers :Smile_honoring:  

Hey great stuff please do. I focused on the Scheer because of that great raider tradition the Imperial Navy set with the Königsberg, Karlsruhe and above all the Emden. The Scheer jumps out at you and it would be great if she could somehow appear in the game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22,932
[HINON]
Supertester
19,241 posts
12,789 battles
1 hour ago, warheart1992 said:

Nice writeup +1! Though I think it's Scheer instead of Sheer. Btw, did the ship have any differences from the rest of the class, or were all identical ?

See this thread by the late dseehafer.

  • Cool 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
517
[POP]
Members
1,166 posts
15,101 battles

H

Well that settles it after looking back at Dseehahfer's work we definitely need all 3 ships in game.

Three almost differently constructed and recontructed ships but from the same class.

Its a WOWS must  

No ship  paste clones

regards  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
1 minute ago, WolfofWarship said:

Well written, thanks for sharing @Stauffenberg44

Sure if that isn't splendid to read first thing in the morning. You're welcome.

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,307
[PVE]
[PVE]
Members
4,113 posts
8,680 battles
On 5/13/2018 at 7:57 PM, Stauffenberg44 said:

The Graf Spee and her fate is well-known; far less appreciated are the exploits of her sister ship Admiral Scheer.

Thanks for posting this, I wish both the Admiral Scheer and the Deutschland would be added to the game in the German Cruiser's Research Line as a sub-branch.

Or even as their own Premium Ships, and maybe the CV conversion of them that the German talked about in 1943.

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
1 minute ago, Chaos_EN2 said:

Thanks for posting this, I wish both the Admiral Scheer and the Deutschland would be added to the game in the German Cruiser's Research Line as a sub-branch.

Yes exactly that would be ideal. And yw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,463
[-K-]
Members
5,295 posts
9,129 battles
On 5/13/2018 at 7:57 PM, Stauffenberg44 said:

It's a pity she will not appear in WoWs.

Never say never.  WG isn't afraid to copy/paste premiums while adding a gimmick or credit/XP earning modifier to justify its existence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,307
[PVE]
[PVE]
Members
4,113 posts
8,680 battles
6 minutes ago, Stauffenberg44 said:

Yes exactly that would be ideal. And yw.

NP, I love my little HSF Graf Spee, it has been my go to ship since I bought it. My proudest moment in her, is when I drove between to USN BBs and sunk them with my torpedoes. I was hurting after that and to do a running fire fight with a Buddy, but still I survived thanks to a teammate.

 

Edited by Chaos_EN2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
2 minutes ago, Ace_04 said:

Never say never.  WG isn't afraid to copy/paste premiums while adding a gimmick or credit/XP earning modifier to justify its existence.

You're right and I changed the phrasing of that.

I wonder what the "gimmick" would be on her? How about making her a campaign gift ship and include the gift Captain Theodor Krancke who gives a +5% speed and and -10% detection bonuses...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,307
[PVE]
[PVE]
Members
4,113 posts
8,680 battles
5 minutes ago, Ace_04 said:

Never say never.  WG isn't afraid to copy/paste premiums while adding a gimmick or credit/XP earning modifier to justify its existence.

I would love to have all three sitting  in my port.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
3,564 posts
6,905 battles
8 minutes ago, Chaos_EN2 said:

NP, I love my little HSF Graf Spee, it has been my go to ship since I bought it. My proudest moment in her, is when I drove between to USN BBs and sunk them with my torpedoes. I was hurting after that and to do a running fire fight with a Buddy, but still I survived thanks to a teammate.

 

I really enjoy her because she exemplifies a unique premium ship, not just a tech tree clone with a gimmick. She ranks right up there with Atago, and both are two of the most beautiful ships in the game as well.

5afad1889fe4a_GrafSpee.jpg.7cb144f5a8a0d4a68f652e7902032f62.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,307
[PVE]
[PVE]
Members
4,113 posts
8,680 battles
17 minutes ago, Stauffenberg44 said:

I really enjoy her because she exemplifies a unique premium ship, not just a tech tree clone with a gimmick. She ranks right up there with Atago, and both are two of the most beautiful ships in the game as well.

Yes, she is, if I could/afford I would get the non- High school Fleet version of the Spee too. Since you can have both in port, I would jump Thea between the two until she got to 19pts she is at 17pts now.

Edited by Chaos_EN2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Beta Testers
1,330 posts
3,591 battles

Hmm would need to be different maybe speed boost and enhanced secondary range. Too bad we don't have defensive secondary fire as a consumable it could be unique to cruisers. Secondaries fire twice as fast for 60 seconds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Members
1,550 posts
8,238 battles

Hey

You have to admit; the Graf Spee is an awesome looking ship and is a great commerce raider platform, which can easily take on cruisers and sink any shipping and most of their escorts.  Too bad Wargaming would let us select names of like ships in the same class:  Deutschland (later renamed Lutzow in Nov. 1939) was the lead ship, Admiral Scheer, Admiral Graf Spee.  Both the surviving ships had received upgraded AA during the war, but ultimately were taken out of surface action by allied efforts.  I love my Graf Spee and find it to be a very good ship.

 

Pete

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,273
[RKLES]
Members
7,214 posts
9,006 battles

All 3 of the “ Pocket Battleships” being in game would be nice. Maybe if Wargaming does a second German Cruiser Line or even a Battlecruiser Line they could slip Deutschland in as regular tech tree or perhaps under her other name the Lutzow, and then add Admiral Scheer in as another premium ship.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
388
[C-CA]
[C-CA]
Beta Testers, In AlfaTesters
1,423 posts
3,367 battles

There were plans for at least two Panzerschiffe classes beyond the Deutschland trio, so it's possible that they could be included as an alternate cruiser branch if they were to be put into the tech tree in the same way that the M-class and Spahkreuzer would be interesting high-tier destroyer leader candidates.

Actually I've got a curious question for those more knowledgeable of the German line's development: Why exactly is the Nurnberg not called Leipzig in-game, seeing as that was the class name ship and Nurnberg was merely her sister-ship.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×