Kurfurst too OP

[Ayanami_Kai]

I've been targeted by Hakuryu like many times, and most of its Torpedo and Bombers never misses

But Kurfurst manage them all with Premium Consumables and Flags, I cannot tell how much Torpedo has hit me.

 

I saw the Yamato got taken down in just the 2nd Wave of Hakuryu's Attack ( Bombers and Torpedo planes ) first wave took 50k of Yamato's health then died on the 2nd wave

But me, its like 6 times he tried to sink me but always fails ( mostly per wave damage is i think like in between 10-25k Damage )

I even got Dreadnaught and Secondary kill ( XD, i used the Secondary Spec which is i had 10.6km range on Manual Firing )

And took out Bismarck in no time, and sadly, the shells i shot to CV was in mid-air when the battle ended, if the battle didnt end, the shell i fired could have killed the CV

 

German Bias too much 

PT Server

[ValkyrWarframe]

How about this (yeah it was on PT).

[poeticmotion]

You seriously just walked in here and made a thread to pronounce a ship OP based solely on the test server and your performance against a t10 CV one time. 

 

Um, dude, a lot of people play high-tier ships on test server they've never played before. That Hakuryu driver may have never played CVs before. And the meta is totally different on test server since it blends all 4 public servers and almost everyone is playing tier 10, even those who don't own anything above a t5 on main server. 

 

Your argument is invalid until you try Kurfurst on the main server. Don't get me wrong, she's still a beast, but she is hideously vulnerable to both DD and CV-dropped torps if you're not very aware of your surroundings and positioning and/or time your hydro use well. That's fine; I'm a DD main so I have a pretty good sense for what DDs will do and can usually avoid getting stealthtorped unless I do something dumb. Every ship needs a weakness. But your argument that Kurfurst is invulnerable to CVs is hilarious because torps will tear her [edited]up. She's an EXTREMELY strong ship. But she's not OP. 

 

(and if she is, shhhh! Don't let them nerf my beloved Kurfurst)

[Herr_Reitz]

After playing Bismarck in a number of matches with T9 and T10... if anything is OP at T10 it would be a couple of cruisers and a DD I could name... but not this BB... nope. Seen too many sink, sunk, gone. 

[mohawkdriver]

Here we go, some PT troll coming in here and wailing "This ship OP cause I did well in it!"  Please just go away and don't come back.

 

[Jester04]

As someone who has over 100 matches in the Kurfurst, I can say its NOT OP. Good: yes, OP: no.  If it's torp dmg reduction was increased to Yam levels with the same turning radius then yes it would be OP.  Granted, I've had a 283k dmg game in mine. (http://wowreplays.com/Replay/22505-Jester04-Gro%C3%9Fer%20Kurf%C3%BCrst-Warriors_Path for those interested) Even still, I be critical of the faults it has.

[Oeldoh]

As someone who has over 100 matches in the Kurfurst, I can say its NOT OP. Good: yes, OP: no.  If it's torp dmg reduction was increased to Yam levels with the same turning radius then yes it would be OP.  Granted, I've had a 283k dmg game in mine. (http://wowreplays.com/Replay/22505-Jester04-Gro%C3%9Fer%20Kurf%C3%BCrst-Warriors_Path for those interested) Even still, I be critical of the faults it has.

 

Exactly, every ship has strengths and weaknesses. Some like Montana's are a bit broken due to no real carrier threat ATM. When they buff CV's next year Montana might be the BB to have due to how well you can spec it for aa.