Jump to content
  • Content count

    19
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Battles

    1058
  • Clan

    [414TH]

Community Reputation

3 Neutral

About xRemus

  • Rank
    Seaman
  • Profile on the website xRemus
  1. Roma Needs Some Love

    Just had a ranked match in my Roma, CVs negate literally all the stated strengths of Roma haha
  2. Roma Needs Some Love

    Look if I gotta trade 2-3km of stealth for this sigma id do it cause Im not exactly a fan of a ship the size of a building hiding in plain sight. I can also get similer detection on my Konig at tier five and the October Revolution. Also another thing about Roma she needs shorter shell fuses because of the amount of over pens she gets. Even my Yamato doesn't get that many of them. With those tho changes she'd be a great tier 8 but atm she lack threat.
  3. Roma Needs Some Love

    Guilio isn't OP its completely glass, I got deleted by a Kongo in the first 3 minutes of a game because the armor is so thin. The guns and handling are great but by no means is the Guilio another Nikolai which is in my opinion overpowered or Belfast. In my personal opinion the OP ships in this game stand out quite nicely as Lion, Conqueror, Belfast, Black, and Nikolai. I might have missed one but those are the big ones. Ships that literally require no skill to play. Point being by I sold my British Tier 9&10 because it was degrading my ability to play other ships cause they are so strong. Roma on the other hand is not like these, she has well defined weaknesses that being her lack of AA on a tier that sees more carriers then most and her raised citadel which you can use to delete her in a heartbeat from any range. Buffing the sigma isnt gonna make her OP. The only way to do that would be to give her Yamato's 2.1 sigma and even then Roma has 15inch guns unlike the Nikolai which bring bigger guns then any other tier 4 bb. Even Musashi isnt quite OP but dear god she is almost there lol decreasing Roma's vertical dispersion alone down to a respectable level will not make a ship with a higher citadel then most Japanese battleships OP.
  4. Roma Needs Some Love

    I agree, most people are waiting or being put off by the reviews of the ship by iChase and Flamu who both gave her negative reviews on competitive play. Granted both of these players are far better and more experienced then me so had I waited for these reviews I would not have gotten Roma. I feel like a lot of people did buy her then hated her guns then stopped using it leaving only players who actually knew what they're doing in her.
  5. Roma Needs Some Love

    In ranked I have been using the Roma's bow to tank quite a bit, but something about her guns needs to change
  6. Roma Needs Some Love

    I agree it is pretty unrealistic
  7. Roma Needs Some Love

    I by no means want an OP ship as it is unrewarding, main reason I sold my Lion and Conqueror. I just want shorter fused rounds for more pens rather than overpens, better dispersion for more reliable accuracy overall(not asking for NC but just less long/short shots cause I can deal with left right shots), and maybe if WG is feeling nice 20km range.
  8. Roma Needs Some Love

    This right here is my argument, Roma is inferior to the competition and thus not competitive.
  9. Roma Needs Some Love

    The fact remains that this is bar non the least accurate bb per km in the game at tier 8. As was advertised it is for people who enjoy long range gunnery. And as for the pay to win comment I saw come up that was not what I was talking about in the least! I was stating that the price should be lowered to compensate for the major lacking of the ship. What is the primary feature of any warship? Its Armaments, the thing the ship is designed around, thus if the armament performs less than average the price should be lowered
  10. Roma Needs Some Love

    You cannot reliably hit targets beyond max range with the spotter plane due to dispersion
  11. Roma Needs Some Love

    I realize this however Italian guns were high velocity and thus when a shell left the gun it had a high chance of staying on its intended path, I cant say much for Italian gunnery but the level of inaccurate that Roma is inexcusable for a $54 tier 8 bb. Its wholey uncompetitive in its current state. Told all my clan members to stay away.
  12. Roma Needs Some Love

    My major issue is that up down dispersion, really screws with my shots cause I can compensate for left right dispersion but up down? lol thanks I needed a laugh hahaha My last game I had an Atago at 15km and missed 4 long, 1 short, 2 far left, 2 overpens
  13. Roma Needs Some Love

    So I got Roma last night and if my name is any hint I love Italy, Rome, and most certainly the Littorio Class battleship, which is why I was so disappointed when I took her out. I may have been over hyped for my favorite Battleship class of World War Two but it completely undershot most of my expectations. First off tho i'll get the pros out of the way so everybody knows Im not just hating Pros Maneuverability - No battleship I've ever used responds as well as Roma does to commands and you can easily torpedobeat, her acceleration and deceleration are quite good except when your going full then of course it does take a bit to stop. Concealment - Unless a dd is spotting a Roma won't be detected unless it either wants to be or closes to fast. HP Pool - very nice 65,400hp which comes in handy cause the armor is blah Looks - By far (IMO) the sexiest battleship in the game, to include the peppermint flavored bow which is historical :P Torpedo Protection - Not sure why but Roma has 40% Torpedo damage reduction Cons AA - I dont mind this much since there are not many CVs and it was said that itd have terrible AA. Had trouble shooting down T6 planes yesterday but again Im okay with this. Armor - I have some issue with the armor, that being the 130mm plate which eats more citadels then I care to confess and had me literally yelling Mamma Mia when a Colorado decided that he wanted a piece of my angled Roma. It seems to take more damage then my Alabama and Amagi but I think that is just me. Range - Here is where I start have serious problems with the ship, the range is 18.1km which is quite terrible and less then every other tier 8 battleship including Tirpitz and Kii which are not exactly snipers and WG literally said on the post(For people who like to engage at range) So 20km please and ill be good. Willing to bring torp protection and concealment to get that 20km range cause 11.2km detection with full stealth in unnecessary. Guns - Sign this is my biggest issue, like wth I thought Italian BBs were being marketed as having very good AP and yet here is Roma. I can deal with the 18km range and the armor and the AA but this is the part that I hate the most. The dispersion on these guns is absolute terrible at 10km+ and even at 4.6km when I was firing at a Bismarck trying to hit Superstructure my rounds when over and under the ship but none where hitting. Then when the rounds do hit the AP is quite terrible on the penetration damage. Due to the 15inch guns and mm you'll get up-tiered to T10 a lot and you'll struggle of course but even when youp tier I get more pens that do no damage then any other ship and overall landing hits is quite hard. Broadside Nuremberg at 10km, all bb drivers love this, fires full broadside and gets 1 pen -2000(um what?) 2 over pens(seriously) the rest went high or low. RNG played its part(my thoughts) and reengaged and basically the same thing. In conclusion buff the range and dispersion. You can nerf concealment and torp protection all you want but please at least the dispersion and maybe a tweek to how the AP works so it doesn't bounce as often. Overall I would rate her a 6/10. The guns and range really hurt the ship. Yes if you check my stats I did get a Kraken with Roma last night but I was top tier and 3 of those kills were pretty much somebody else did the majority of the damage and I just secured(my most shameful kraken ever at 106k damage). Im averaging around 67% wins but im at around 15 battles now and most of those I had to be carried cause the ship doesn't perform well. Around 60k per battle, for comparison my North Carolina gets me around 92k a match and has 88% wins. Thank you for the read and have a great day!!!
  14. Id very much like to see the A-150 ingame and I'll throw it into the future request post for an alternate Japanese BB line, however I'll also give another tier 10 that will have 18.1inch guns just in case.
  15. Basically our work ended up like this. Tier 7 - Ise Class Tier 8 - Tosa Class Tier 9 - Mikawa Class(Number 13 Class, decided to name it) Tier 10 - Alternate Yamato Design C or H(which can be scene below and my friend named Burakumin Class) The C design is NOT the A-150 and DOES NOT have 20 inch guns as Wargaming said they wouldn't do guns bigger than Yamato's.... that beginning said and without that restriction the A-150 would be the best choice for an alternate Japanese tier 10 due to it having less guns but bigger guns than Yamato. Also as a balancing factor I'd suggest a 35-40 second reload.
×