Jump to content

Captain_Charnage

Members
  • Content Сount

    5
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Battles

    17369
  • Clan

    [DURPX]

Community Reputation

26 Neutral

About Captain_Charnage

Recent Profile Visitors

181 profile views
  1. Captain_Charnage

    Suggested Changes to Subs

    yes but they still couldn't "see" the sub underwater. They had a passive acoustic array location of its heading and speed underwater, and only visual on the surface or periscope. We annually engaged in war games regularly where we would successfully target and identify opposing subs. Still no way to see them.
  2. I am going to start by saying I am a Submariner. I served on an Oberon Class, and I have not only have first hand experience of WW2 subs, but I also was eagerly anticipating subs more than any of my friends. I couldn't sleep the night before launch. This new mode is stunning beautiful. It plays smooth and cleanly. The models are fascinating. This new mode shows off the new capabilities of wows, and exemplified how well a new thought can be implemented. In saying that, I think that new idea of how subs should be implemented is so flawed, it is an unplayable mode. Let me list the mechanics I will discuss: - camera - targeting and torpedoes - 3d combat - ship maneuverability and steering - spotting system - evasion and retreat - underwater environment and sonar map Camera The same camera system was implemented from the surface models. Perhaps this was done for ease or simplification, but it is flawed. The ship is always in your way of seeing what in in front of the boat underwater and is is a constant zooming burden to see what is needed to be seen. The above water camera works fine and needs no adjustment. What is needed, underwater, is for the camera move to top of the conning tower, with the ability to then zoom. Targeting and torpedoes I can see what the developers were trying to do. They were trying to implement something fun and engaging with some difficulty, and implemented a ping twice system for target lock, and torpedoes would "home". This sound good on paper, but what was implemented is a chore. Let me tell you a scenario which you will recognise. You are underwater and you can see a boat 5km away, which is absurd, and you begin your ping sequence. Ping 6 sec wait, shoot 3 sec wait , ping 6 sec wait, but right before the second ping lands on the ship, you find the sonar tracker ends just before the ship for an island that cannot be seen. The ping graphic just ends, no message, no effect. Nothing. It is very frustrating. I will admit being able to fire torpedoes and curve them toward the target is cool, but not cool enough to make it enjoyable, even though this only worked in open water with no island interruptions. The torpedoes should acquire a lock, with no homing, once a ship in inside the torpedo arc for say, 8 seconds. Then you could fire and move on. 3d Combat Again, well intentioned, but I just cannot fathom how this is really going to ever be playable. The ability to hit another sub in a 3d environment close range is so difficult, ramming is a much better solution. Firstly, you can SEE the sub, which is counter intuitive to anyone that expect that with a boat with no windows, that anything should be visible. In boats of this era, you could only fire torps with a visual line of sight, and it was a straight torpedo. why on earth they decided to stray so far from reality is boggling to me. It is near impossible to fire on a sub without pinging it first. Subs should not be able to fire underwater in this mode, underwater should be reserved for evasion only, (to be explained later in the summary). Ship maneuverability and steering This actually is done quite well. careful thought was put into into how the sub performs, and generally it is fun to drive and dive, the only critique I can say is that the usage of F and C to surface and dive requires that you are not pressing E/D at the same time, since it is the same finger required. I moved my keys around a bit so that I and turn right and dive at the same time. Spotting system Done well. The various active, passive, and dive modes combinations was implemented well and made you think on what mode you wanted to be in and when each one was to be used. Evasion and retreat It was easy to go silent and evade boats, with some damage, as expected, and it worked well. Underwater environment and sonar map This was realistic and well implemented, it was easy to see where you were and what path to plot underwater. I would like to see that any ping underwater would not be able to identify a ship by name or type, you would just see a blob to evade, its direction and speed. You should have limited information available to you underwater. Overall summary This new sub mode was partially done very well, and partially a waste of effort, how this mode ever got to this stage is beside me, and I cannot endorse this mode. At all. In order to make this playable they need to make the following changes: 1. Drop the ping targeting of ships/boats. Ships should auto target once in the torpedo arc. same as ships. Torps should only go in a straight line. 2. Drop the ability to have various depths. There should be 3 modes, Surface, periscope and submerged. You can only fire targeted torps in surface and periscope. If you fire torps underwater, they are untargeted. Periscope torps only hit cruisers/battleships, surface torps can hit anything. 3. Drop the camera underwater. you get a sonar map and blobs of ship speed/direction in close range 4. Use the battery charge only as a evasion timer to extract yourself from danger. If you stop, and go silent underwater, the battery drain should go to near zero. 5. Subs should not exceed 25 knots and should have limited compliment of torps with high damage, long range. 6. Subs are only spot-able by any aircraft or ship in surface or periscope mode. 7. At least one single barrel gun should work on the casing of the sub that fires HE only. 8. All ships should have minimally auto depth charges, like AA is auto If you make these changes the game mode will be fun to play.
  3. Captain_Charnage

    Submarine Feedback

    I am going to start by saying I am a Submariner. I served on an Oberon Class, and I have not only have first hand experience of WW2 subs, but I also was eagerly anticipating subs more than any of my friends. I couldn't sleep the night before launch. This new mode is stunning beautiful. It plays smooth and cleanly. The models are fascinating. This new mode shows off the new capabilities of wows, and exemplified how well a new thought can be implemented. In saying that, I think that new idea of how subs should be implemented is so flawed, it is an unplayable mode. Let me list the mechanics I will discuss: - camera - targeting and torpedoes - 3d combat - ship maneuverability and steering - spotting system - evasion and retreat - underwater environment and sonar map Camera The same camera system was implemented from the surface models. Perhaps this was done for ease or simplification, but it is flawed. The ship is always in your way of seeing what in in front of the boat underwater and is is a constant zooming burden to see what is needed to be seen. The above water camera works fine and needs no adjustment. What is needed, underwater, is for the camera move to top of the conning tower, with the ability to then zoom. Targeting and torpedoes I can see what the developers were trying to do. They were trying to implement something fun and engaging with some difficulty, and implemented a ping twice system for target lock, and torpedoes would "home". This sound good on paper, but what was implemented is a chore. Let me tell you a scenario which you will recognise. You are underwater and you can see a boat 5km away, which is absurd, and you begin your ping sequence. Ping 6 sec wait, shoot 3 sec wait , ping 6 sec wait, but right before the second ping lands on the ship, you find the sonar tracker ends just before the ship for an island that cannot be seen. The ping graphic just ends, no message, no effect. Nothing. It is very frustrating. I will admit being able to fire torpedoes and curve them toward the target is cool, but not cool enough to make it enjoyable, even though this only worked in open water with no island interruptions. The torpedoes should acquire a lock, with no homing, once a ship in inside the torpedo arc for say, 8 seconds. Then you could fire and move on. 3d Combat Again, well intentioned, but I just cannot fathom how this is really going to ever be playable. The ability to hit another sub in a 3d environment close range is so difficult, ramming is a much better solution. Firstly, you can SEE the sub, which is counter intuitive to anyone that expect that with a boat with no windows, that anything should be visible. In boats of this era, you could only fire torps with a visual line of sight, and it was a straight torpedo. why on earth they decided to stray so far from reality is boggling to me. It is near impossible to fire on a sub without pinging it first. Subs should not be able to fire underwater in this mode, underwater should be reserved for evasion only, (to be explained later in the summary). Ship maneuverability and steering This actually is done quite well. careful thought was put into into how the sub performs, and generally it is fun to drive and dive, the only critique I can say is that the usage of F and C to surface and dive requires that you are not pressing E/D at the same time, since it is the same finger required. I moved my keys around a bit so that I and turn right and dive at the same time. Spotting system Done well. The various active, passive, and dive modes combinations was implemented well and made you think on what mode you wanted to be in and when each one was to be used. Evasion and retreat It was easy to go silent and evade boats, with some damage, as expected, and it worked well. Underwater environment and sonar map This was realistic and well implemented, it was easy to see where you were and what path to plot underwater. I would like to see that any ping underwater would not be able to identify a ship by name or type, you would just see a blob to evade, its direction and speed. You should have limited information available to you underwater. Overall summary This new sub mode was partially done very well, and partially a waste of effort, how this mode ever got to this stage is beside me, and I cannot endorse this mode. At all. In order to make this playable they need to make the following changes: 1. Drop the ping targeting of ships/boats. Ships should auto target once in the torpedo arc. same as ships. Torps should only go in a straight line. 2. Drop the ability to have various depths. There should be 3 modes, Surface, periscope and submerged. You can only fire targeted torps in surface and periscope. If you fire torps underwater, they are untargeted. Periscope torps only hit cruisers/battleships, surface torps can hit anything. 3. Drop the camera underwater. you get a sonar map and blobs of ship speed/direction in close range 4. Use the battery charge only as a evasion timer to extract yourself from danger. If you stop, and go silent underwater, the battery drain should go to near zero. 5. Subs should not exceed 25 knots and should have limited compliment of torps with high damage, long range. 6. Subs are only spot-able by any aircraft or ship in surface or periscope mode. 7. At least one single barrel gun should work on the casing of the sub that fires HE only. 8. All ships should have minimally auto depth charges, like AA is auto If you make these changes the game mode will be fun to play.
  4. Captain_Charnage

    CV Rework Feedback

    so true, not spending any money till this is fixed
×